FN Archimer Export Format PT J TI Different surveys provide similar pictures of trends in a marine fish community but not of individual fish populations BT AF TRENKEL, Verena PINNEGAR, John ROCHET, Marie-Joelle RACKHAM, Brian AS 1:;2:;3:;4:; FF 1:PDG-DRV-RH-MAERHA;2:;3:PDG-DRV-RH-MAERHA;4:; C1 IFREMER, Lab MAERHA, F-44311 Nantes 3, France. Ctr Environm Fisheries & Aquaculture Sci, Lowestoft Lab, Lowestoft NR33 0HT, Suffolk, England. C2 IFREMER, FRANCE CEFAS, UK SI NANTES SE PDG-DRV-RH-MAERHA IN WOS Ifremer jusqu'en 2018 copubli-europe IF 1.105 TC 23 UR https://archimer.ifremer.fr/doc/2004/publication-899.pdf LA English DT Article CR EVHOE 2000 EVHOE 871 EVHOE 882 EVHOE 883 EVHOE 894 EVHOE 905 EVHOE 916 EVHOE 927 EVHOE 948 EVHOE 959 EVHOE 97 EVHOE 98 EVHOE 99 BO Thalassa DE ;Trawl;Survey;Species diversity;Size spectrum;Celtic Sea;Abundance AB Choice of sampling method and survey period can have an important impact on the perception of the structure and dynamics of an ecological community. For the Celtic Sea fish assemblage we compared data obtained by three different trawl surveys: an autumn groundfish survey with a GOV trawl, and a spring and an autumn groundfish survey, both carried out with a Portuguese high-headline trawl. Time-series of abundance estimates were not consistent among surveys for all species and were generally very noisy. An analysis of variance components showed that the sampling method contributed more to the variance in abundance estimates compared to survey period, interannual variability, or even sampling variance. Overall community assessments based on indicators such as proportions of non-commercial and piscivorous species, and the proportion of benthic species showed similar trends for all data series. The shape of the size spectrum based on abundances per length class summed over all fish species, although stable over time, was highly sensitive to the sampling method. With the exception of size spectra, community indicators for marine fish assemblages monitored by surveys seem to be robust to survey period and trawling gear, but species abundance trends are method dependent. PY 2004 PD MAY SO ICES Journal of Marine Science SN 1054-3139 PU Elsevier VL 61 IS 3 UT 000221440300005 BP 351 EP 362 DI 10.1016/j.icesjms.2004.01.004 ID 899 ER EF