Reply to: Shark mortality cannot be assessed by fishery overlap alone

Type Article
Date 2021-07
Language English
Author(s) Queiroz Nuno1, 2, Humphries Nicolas E.2, Couto Ana1, Vedor Marisa1, 3, Da Costa Ivo1, Sequeira Ana M. M.4, 5, Mucientes Gonzalo1, Santos Antonio M1, 3, Abascal Francisco J.6, Abercrombie Debra L.7, 8, Abrantes Katya, Acuna-Marrero David9, Afonso Andre S.10, 11, Afonso Pedro12, 13, 14, Anders Darrell15, Araujo Gonzalo16, Arauz Randall17, 18, 19, Bach Pascal112, Barnett Adam, Bernal Diego21, Berumen Michael L.22, Bessudo Lion Sandra19, 23, Bezerra Natalia P. A.10, Blaison Antonin V.112, Block Barbara A.24, Bond Mark E.25, Bonfil Ramon26, Bradford Russell W.27, Braun Camrin D.28, 29, Brooks Edward J.30, Brooks Annabelle30, 31, Brown Judith32, Bruce Barry D.27, Byrne Michael E.33, 34, Campana Steven E.35, Carlisle Aaron B.36, Chapman Demian D.25, Chapple Taylor K.24, 110, Chisholm John37, Clarke Christopher R.38, Clua Eric G.39, Cochran Jesse E. M.22, Crochelet Estelle C.40, 41, Dagorn Laurent112, Daly Ryan42, 43, Devia Cortes Daniel4, Doyle Thomas K.45, 46, Drew Michael47, Duffy Clinton A. J.48, Erikson Thor49, Espinoza Eduardo19, 50, Ferreira Luciana C.51, Ferretti Francesco52, Filmalter John D.43, 112, Fischer G. Chris53, Fitzpatrick Richard, Fontes Jorge12, 13, 14, Forget Fabien112, Fowler Mark54, Francis Malcolm P.55, Gallagher Austin J.56, 57, Gennari Enrico43, 58, 59, Goldsworthy Simon D.60, Gollock Matthew J.61, Green Jonathan R.62, Gustafson Johan A.63, Guttridge Tristan L.64, Guzman Hector M.65, Hammerschlag Neil57, 66, Harman Luke45, Hazin Fabio H. V.10, Heard Matthew47, Hearn Alex R.19, 67, 68, Holdsworth John C.69, Holmes Bonnie J.70, 111, Howey Lucy A.71, Hoyos Mauricio19, 72, Hueter Robert E., Hussey Nigel E.74, Huveneers Charlie47, Irion Dylan T.75, Jacoby David M. P.78, Jewell Oliver J. D.77, 78, Johnson Ryan79, Jordan Lance K. B.71, Joyce Warren54, Daly Clare A. Keating42, Ketchum James T.19, 72, Klimley A. Peter19, 80, Kock Alison A.43, 81, 82, 83, Koen Pieter84, Ladino Felipe23, Lana Fernanda O.10, 85, Lea James S. E.38, 86, Llewellyn Fiona61, Lyon Warrick S.55, Macdonnell Anna54, Macena Bruno C. L.10, 13, Marshall Heather21, 87, McAllister Jaime D.88, Meyer Michael A.15, Morris John J., Nelson Emily R.57, Papastamatiou Yannis P.25, Penaherrera-Palma Cesar19, 69, Pierce Simon J.90, Poisson Francois20, Maria Quintero Lina23, Richardson Andrew J.91, Rogers Paul J.60, Rohner Christoph A.90, Rowat David R. L.92, Samoilys Melita93, Semmens Jayson M.88, Sheaves Marcus, Shillinger George19, 24, 94, Shivji Mahmood33, Singh Sarika15, Skomal Gregory B.36, Smale Malcolm J.95, 96, Snyders Laurenne B.15, Soler German19, 23, 88, Soria Marc112, Stehfest Kilian M.88, Thorrold Simon R.29, Tolotti Mariana T.112, Towner Alison59, 78, Travassos Paulo10, Tyminski John P., Vandeperre Frederic12, 13, 14, Vaudo Jeremy J.33, Watanabe Yuuki Y.97, 98, Weber Sam B.99, Wetherbee Bradley M.33, 100, White Timothy D.24, Williams Sean30, Zarate Patricia M.101, Harcourt Robert102, Hays Graeme C.103, Meekan Mark G.51, Thums Michele51, Irigoien Xabier104, 105, Eguiluz Victor M.106, Duarte Carlos M.ORCID22, Sousa Lara L.2, 107, Simpson Samantha J.2, 108, Southall Emily J.2, Sims David W.2, 108, 109
Affiliation(s) 1 : Univ Porto, Ctr Invest Biodivers & Recursos Genet, Res Network Biodivers & Evolutionary Biol, Campus Agr Vairao, Vairao, Portugal.
2 : Marine Biol Assoc UK, Plymouth, Devon, England.
3 : Univ Porto, Dept Biol, Fac Ciencias, Porto, Portugal.
4 : Univ Western Australia, UWA Oceans Inst, Indian Ocean Marine Res Ctr, Crawley, WA, Australia.
5 : Univ Western Australia, Sch Biol Sci, Crawley, WA, Australia.
6 : Spanish Inst Oceanog, Santa Cruz De Tenerife, Spain.
7 : Abercrombie & Fish, Port Jefferson Stn, NY USA.
8 : James Cook Univ, Coll Sci & Engn, Marine Biol & Aquaculture Unit, Cairns, Qld, Australia.
9 : Massey Univ, Inst Nat & Math Sci, Palmerston North, New Zealand.
10 : Univ Fed Rural Pernambuco UFRPE, Dept Pesca & Aquicultura, Recife, PE, Brazil.
11 : Inst Politecn Leiria, Marine & Environm Sci Ctr, MARE, Peniche, Portugal.
12 : Univ Lisbon, Lab Maritimo Guia, MARE, Fac Ciencias, Cascais, Portugal.
13 : Univ Acores, Dept Oceanog & Pescas, Inst Marine Res IMAR, Horta, Portugal.
14 : Univ Acores, Okeanos Dept Oceanog & Pescas, Horta, Portugal.
15 : Dept Environm Affairs Oceans & Coasts Res, Cape Town, South Africa.
16 : Large Marine Vertebrates Res Inst Philippines, Jagna, Philippines.
17 : Fins Attached Marine Res & Conservat, Colorado Springs, CO USA.
18 : Programa Restaurac Tortugas Marinas PRETOMA, San Jose, Costa Rica.
19 : MigraMar, Olema, CA USA.
20 : Univ Montpellier, IFREMER, Inst Rech Dev, CNRS,UMR,MARBEC,IRD, Sete, France.
21 : Univ Massachusetts, Dept Biol, Dartmouth, MA USA.
22 : King Abdullah Univ Sci & Technol, Div Biol & Environm Sci & Engn, Red Sea Res Ctr, Thuwal, Saudi Arabia.
23 : Fdn Malpelo & Otros Ecosistemas Marinos, Bogota, Colombia.
24 : Stanford Univ, Hopkins Marine Stn, Pacific Grove, CA 93950 USA.
25 : Florida Int Univ, Dept Biol Sci, North Miami, FL USA.
26 : Univ Fed Ceara, Inst Ciencias Mar, Fortaleza, Ceara, Brazil.
27 : CSIRO Oceans & Atmosphere, Hobart, Tas, Australia.
28 : Univ Washington, Sch Aquat & Fishery Sci, Seattle, WA 98195 USA.
29 : Woods Hole Oceanog Inst, Dept Biol, Woods Hole, MA 02543 USA.
30 : Cape Eleuthera Inst, Shark Res & Conservat Program, Eleuthera, Bahamas.
31 : Univ Exeter, Exeter, Devon, England.
32 : South Atlantic Environm Res Inst, Stanley, Falkland Island.
33 : Nova Southeastern Univ, Dept Biol Sci, Guy Harvey Res Inst, Dania, FL USA.
34 : Univ Missouri, Sch Nat Resources, Columbia, MO USA.
35 : Univ Iceland, Life & Environm Sci, Reykjavik, Iceland.
36 : Univ Delaware, Sch Marine Sci & Policy, Lewes, DE 19958 USA.
37 : Massachusetts Div Marine Fisheries, New Bedford, MA USA.
38 : Marine Res Facil, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
39 : CNRS, EPHE, UPVD, PSL,Labex CORAIL,CRIOBE,USR3278, Papetoai, French Polynesi, France.
40 : Agence Rech Biodivers Reunion ARBRE, Marseille, Reunion, France.
41 : Inst Rech Dev, ESPACE DEV, UMR 228, Marseille, Reunion, France.
42 : Save Our Seas Fdn, Arros Res Ctr SOSF DRC, Geneva, Switzerland.
43 : South African Inst Aquat Biodivers SAIAB, Grahamstown, South Africa.
44 : Inst Fomento Pesquero IFOP, Fisheries Res Div, Dept Fisheries Evaluat, Valparaiso, Chile.
45 : Univ Coll Cork, Sch Biol Earth & Environm Sci, Cork, Ireland.
46 : Univ Coll Cork, Environm Res Inst, MaREI Ctr, Cork, Ireland.
47 : Flinders Univ S Australia, Coll Sci & Engn, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
48 : Dept Conservat, Auckland, New Zealand.
49 : UKZN, South African Inst Aquat Biodivers, Geol Sci, Durban, South Africa.
50 : Direcc Parque Nacl Galapagos, Puerto Ayora, Galapagos, Ecuador.
51 : Indian Ocean Marine Res Ctr UWA, Australian Inst Marine Sci, Crawley, WA, Australia.
52 : Virginia Tech, Dept Fish & Wildlife Conservat, Blacksburg, VA USA.
53 : OCEARCH, Park City, UT USA.
54 : Bedford Inst Oceanog, Dartmouth, NS, Canada.
55 : Natl Inst Water & Atmospher Res, Wellington, New Zealand.
56 : Beneath Waves, Herndon, VA USA.
57 : Univ Miami, Rosenstiel Sch Marine & Atmospher Sci, 4600 Rickenbacker Causeway, Miami, FL 33149 USA.
58 : Oceans Res Inst, Mossel Bay, South Africa.
59 : Rhodes Univ, Dept Ichthyol & Fisheries Sci, Grahamstown, South Africa.
60 : SARDI Aquat Sci, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
61 : Zool Soc London, London, England.
62 : Galapagos Whale Shark Project, Puerto Ayora, Galapagos, Ecuador.
63 : Griffith Univ, Sch Engn, Griffith Ctr Coastal Management, Gold Coast, Qld, Australia.
64 : Saving Blue, Cooper City, FL USA.
65 : Smithsonian Trop Res Inst, Panama City, Panama.
66 : Univ Miami, Leonard & Jayne Abess Ctr Ecosyst Sci & Policy, Coral Gables, FL 33124 USA.
67 : Galapagos Sci Ctr, San Cristobal, Galapagos, Ecuador.
68 : Univ San Francisco Quito, Quito, Ecuador.
69 : Blue Water Marine Res, Tutukaka, New Zealand.
70 : Univ Queensland, Brisbane, Qld, Australia.
71 : Microwave Telemetry, Columbia, MD USA.
72 : Pelagios Kakunja, La Paz, Mexico.
73 : Ctr Shark Res, Mote Marine Lab, Sarasota, FL USA.
74 : Univ Windsor, Biol Sci, Windsor, ON, Canada.
75 : Cape Res & Diver Dev, Simonstown, South Africa.
76 : Zool Soc London, Inst Zool, London, England.
77 : Murdoch Univ, Harry Butler Inst, Ctr Sustainable Aquat Ecosyst, Perth, WA, Australia.
78 : Dyer Isl Conservat Trust, Western Cape, South Africa.
79 : Blue Wilderness Res Unit, Scottburgh, South Africa.
80 : Univ Calif Davis, Davis, CA 95616 USA.
81 : South African Natl Pk, Cape Res Ctr, Steenberg, South Africa.
82 : Shark Spotters, Fish Hoek, South Africa.
83 : Univ Cape Town, Dept Biol Sci, Inst Communities & Wildlife Africa, Rondebosch, South Africa.
84 : Western Cape Dept Agr, Vet Serv, Elsenburg, South Africa.
85 : Univ Fed Fluminense UFF, Dept Biol Marinha, Niteroi, RJ, Brazil.
86 : Univ Cambridge, Dept Zool, Cambridge, England.
87 : Atlantic White Shark Conservancy, Chatham, MA USA.
88 : Univ Tasmania, Inst Marine & Antarctic Studies, Fisheries & Aquaculture Ctr, Hobart, Tas, Australia.
89 : Pontificia Univ Catolica Ecuador Sede Manabi, Portoviejo, Ecuador.
90 : Marine Megafauna Fdn, Truckee, CA USA.
91 : Ascens Isl Govt, Conservat & Fisheries Dept, Georgetown, Ascension Island, UK.
92 : Marine Conservat Soc Seychelles, Victoria, Seychelles.
93 : CORDIO, Mombasa, Kenya.
94 : Upwell, Monterey, CA USA.
95 : Nelson Mandela Univ, Dept Zool, Port Elizabeth, South Africa.
96 : Nelson Mandela Univ, Inst Coastal & Marine Res, Port Elizabeth, South Africa.
97 : Natl Inst Polar Res, Tachikawa, Tokyo, Japan.
98 : SOKENDAI Grad Univ Adv Studies, Tachikawa, Tokyo, Japan.
99 : Univ Exeter, Ctr Ecol & Conservat, Penryn, England.
100 : Univ Rhode Isl, Dept Biol Sci, Kingston, RI 02881 USA.
101 : Inst Fomento Pesquero IFOP, Fisheries Res Div, Dept Oceanog & Environm, Valparaiso, Chile.
102 : Macquarie Univ, Dept Biol Sci, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
103 : Deakin Univ, Sch Life & Environm Sci, Geelong, Vic, Australia.
104 : AZTI BRTA, Pasaia, Spain.
105 : Basque Fdn Sci, Ikerbasque, Bilbao, Spain.
106 : Univ Balear Isl, Inst Fis Interdisciplinar & Sistemas Complejos, CSIC, Palma De Mallorca, Spain.
107 : Univ Oxford, Dept Zool, Wildlife Conservat Res Unit, Tubney, England.
108 : Univ Southampton, Natl Oceanog Ctr Southampton, Ocean & Earth Sci, Southampton, Hants, England.
109 : Univ Southampton, Ctr Biol Sci, Southampton, Hants, England.
110 : Oregon State Univ, Hatfield Marine Sci Ctr, Newport, OR USA.
111 : Univ Sunshine Coast, Sippy Downs, Qld, Australia.
112 : Univ Montpellier, IFREMER, Inst Rech Dev, CNRS,UMR,MARBEC,IRD, Sete, France.
Source Nature (0028-0836) (Springer Science and Business Media LLC), 2021-07 , Vol. 595 , N. 7866 , P. E14-E24
DOI 10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3
Full Text
File Pages Size Access
Supplementary Methods and Supplementary Tables 1-16 9 556 KB Open access
Reporting Summary 2 69 KB Open access
Publisher's official version 11 3 MB Open access
Top of the page

How to cite 

Queiroz Nuno, Humphries Nicolas E., Couto Ana, Vedor Marisa, Da Costa Ivo, Sequeira Ana M. M., Mucientes Gonzalo, Santos Antonio M, Abascal Francisco J., Abercrombie Debra L., Abrantes Katya, Acuna-Marrero David, Afonso Andre S., Afonso Pedro, Anders Darrell, Araujo Gonzalo, Arauz Randall, Bach Pascal, Barnett Adam, Bernal Diego, Berumen Michael L., Bessudo Lion Sandra, Bezerra Natalia P. A., Blaison Antonin V., Block Barbara A., Bond Mark E., Bonfil Ramon, Bradford Russell W., Braun Camrin D., Brooks Edward J., Brooks Annabelle, Brown Judith, Bruce Barry D., Byrne Michael E., Campana Steven E., Carlisle Aaron B., Chapman Demian D., Chapple Taylor K., Chisholm John, Clarke Christopher R., Clua Eric G., Cochran Jesse E. M., Crochelet Estelle C., Dagorn Laurent, Daly Ryan, Devia Cortes Daniel, Doyle Thomas K., Drew Michael, Duffy Clinton A. J., Erikson Thor, Espinoza Eduardo, Ferreira Luciana C., Ferretti Francesco, Filmalter John D., Fischer G. Chris, Fitzpatrick Richard, Fontes Jorge, Forget Fabien, Fowler Mark, Francis Malcolm P., Gallagher Austin J., Gennari Enrico, Goldsworthy Simon D., Gollock Matthew J., Green Jonathan R., Gustafson Johan A., Guttridge Tristan L., Guzman Hector M., Hammerschlag Neil, Harman Luke, Hazin Fabio H. V., Heard Matthew, Hearn Alex R., Holdsworth John C., Holmes Bonnie J., Howey Lucy A., Hoyos Mauricio, Hueter Robert E., Hussey Nigel E., Huveneers Charlie, Irion Dylan T., Jacoby David M. P., Jewell Oliver J. D., Johnson Ryan, Jordan Lance K. B., Joyce Warren, Daly Clare A. Keating, Ketchum James T., Klimley A. Peter, Kock Alison A., Koen Pieter, Ladino Felipe, Lana Fernanda O., Lea James S. E., Llewellyn Fiona, Lyon Warrick S., Macdonnell Anna, Macena Bruno C. L., Marshall Heather, McAllister Jaime D., Meyer Michael A., Morris John J., Nelson Emily R., Papastamatiou Yannis P., Penaherrera-Palma Cesar, Pierce Simon J., Poisson Francois, Maria Quintero Lina, Richardson Andrew J., Rogers Paul J., Rohner Christoph A., Rowat David R. L., Samoilys Melita, Semmens Jayson M., Sheaves Marcus, Shillinger George, Shivji Mahmood, Singh Sarika, Skomal Gregory B., Smale Malcolm J., Snyders Laurenne B., Soler German, Soria Marc, Stehfest Kilian M., Thorrold Simon R., Tolotti Mariana T., Towner Alison, Travassos Paulo, Tyminski John P., Vandeperre Frederic, Vaudo Jeremy J., Watanabe Yuuki Y., Weber Sam B., Wetherbee Bradley M., White Timothy D., Williams Sean, Zarate Patricia M., Harcourt Robert, Hays Graeme C., Meekan Mark G., Thums Michele, Irigoien Xabier, Eguiluz Victor M., Duarte Carlos M., Sousa Lara L., Simpson Samantha J., Southall Emily J., Sims David W. (2021). Reply to: Shark mortality cannot be assessed by fishery overlap alone. Nature, 595(7866), E14-E24. Publisher's official version : https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3 , Open Access version : https://archimer.ifremer.fr/doc/00705/81666/