Comparison of Mediterranean Pteropod Shell Biometrics and Ultrastructure from Historical (1910 and 1921) and Present Day (2012) Samples Provides Baseline for Monitoring Effects of Global Change

Anthropogenic carbon perturbation has caused decreases in seawater pH and increases in global temperatures since the start of the 20th century. The subsequent lowering of the saturation state of CaCO3 may make the secretion of skeletons more problematic for marine calcifiers. As organisms that precipitate thin aragonite shells, thecosome pteropods have been identified as being particularly vulnerable to climate change effects. Coupled with their global distribution, this makes them ideal for use as sentinel organisms. Recent studies have highlighted shell dissolution as a potential indicator of ocean acidification; however, this metric is not applicable for monitoring pH changes in supersaturated basins. In this study, the novel approach of high resolution computed tomography (CT) scanning was used to produce quantitative 3-dimensional renderings pteropod shells to assess the potential of using this method to monitor small changes in shell biometrics that may be driven by climate change drivers. An ontogenetic analysis of the shells of Cavolinia inflexa and Styliola subula collected from the Mediterranean was used to identify suitable monitoring metrics. Modern samples were then compared to historical samples of the same species, collected during the Mediterranean leg of the Thor (1910) and Dana (1921) cruises to assess whether any empirical differences could be detected. Shell densities were calculated and scanning electron microscopy was used to compare the aragonite crystal morphology. pH for the collection years was hind-cast using temperature and salinity time series with atmospheric CO2 concentrations from ice core data. Historical samples of S. subula were thicker than S. subula shells of the same size from 2012 and C. inflexa shells collected in 1910 were significantly denser than those from 2012. These results provide a baseline for future work to develop monitoring techniques for climate change in the oceans using the novel approach of high-resolution CT scanning.

Full Text

FilePagesSizeAccess
Publisher's official version
233 Mo
S1 Fig. Screenshot of initial 3D reconstruction of a typical CT scan in VG StudioMax software.
1180 Ko
S2 Fig. Objects in the initial reconstruction are separated into three distinct files using a process called 3-2-1 registration.
1314 Ko
S3 Fig. Individual objects are now ready for dimension, thickness, and volume analyses.
1342 Ko
S4 Fig. In some cases extraneous objects in the mount were not removable based on greyscale intensity differences, for example see the “floating material above and below the shell in the top panel.
2516 Ko
S5 Fig.
2451 Ko
S1 Table. Time series of measured water temperature, salinity and corbonate chemistry parameters taken from Point B from 2007–2012, used to validate hindcast modeling of pH.
11484 Ko
S2 Table. Modern specimens used in analysis of shell morphometrics based on ontogenetic stage.
3208 Ko
S3 Table. The modern and museum specimens used for comparison.
3304 Ko
How to cite
Howes Ella L., Eagle Robert A., Gattuso Jean-Pierre, Bijma Jelle (2017). Comparison of Mediterranean Pteropod Shell Biometrics and Ultrastructure from Historical (1910 and 1921) and Present Day (2012) Samples Provides Baseline for Monitoring Effects of Global Change. Plos One. 12 (1). e0167891 (23p.). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0167891, https://archimer.ifremer.fr/doc/00377/48792/

Copy this text